“No, No, No!” If you have a toddler, you know what this
sounds like. It’s frustrating, it’s aggravating, and it makes you late for
work, or wastes the meal you carefully made, or causes your child to miss her bedtime.
But the toddler’s “no” is also more than that, and understanding the full
message allows parents and caregivers to better respond to and interact with
the resistant toddler in full throttle.
There are actually two meanings contained within the
toddler’s no: the action or event the toddler is resisting, and then the
ability to resist, in and of itself. When the child refuses to put on his shoes
as you’re desperately trying to leave the house in the morning, at issue are
the shoes, and his ability to say “no” to you, the all powerful parent. Often
enough in the heat of the moment, parents react to the first part of the
message and put even stronger demands on the child to put her shoes on “now!”
But this drowns out what is likely to be more important to the child in that
moment, which is the second part, the refusal. Addressing the refusal rather
than the shoes, can dramatically change the interaction, and can often (but not
always) change the “no” into a “yes.” Even more importantly, understanding what
is important to your toddler and forming a habit of responding to it accurately
can set you and her up for improved interactions in the long-term, and provides
her a model for dealing with her relationships in general. In short, thinking
about what the “no” means to the toddler is an important teaching moment, for
both child and parent together.
What might this look like, addressing the refusal rather
than the shoes? In a moment we will look at some examples of how to do this,
but building your own understanding of what it means to your child to refuse
your directions, and what kinds of feelings it generates within you as she does
so really involves getting to know your child better – as well as yourself. While
techniques can be useful, no one way will work for all children, and none will
work for any given child all of the time. It can, however, be helpful to keep some
in your tool chest as options to keep in mind and try out with your own child.
For example, one I’ve found helpful is making it explicit to the child that she
is refusing – because as surprising as it may be – until you say it out loud –
children are often unaware of the meaning of their actions, and what the impact
of their actions are on others. As adults, we struggle with this, too.
Let’s say you are trying to get your child to put her shoes
on by the front door, but instead of complying, the child runs out of the door
barefoot. Securing the child, of course, comes first. But once you have child
in hand try saying, calmly, even playfully: “you don’t want to listen to
mommy/daddy right now, do you?” This names and describes the behavior to the
child so that it’s out in the open; it also makes the child feel that an
important need of hers has been acknowledged and heard. As an adult you know
that kind of acknowledgment of real feelings, what one might call empathy, can
be very powerful in your adult relationships. It should come as no surprise
that it works for children as well. And ideally, empathy is never a technique.
Trying this kind of approach requires spending an extra minute or two with the
child as she negotiates with you this new information – something that can be
hard for you to do on a busy morning. But what you get in return is a no-fuss
morning with you and her still enjoying each other’s company at the end: and
that, of course, is the point, while often challenging, parenting is supposed
to be fun, not a chore.
Another approach is waiting out the “no.” Let’s say you are
brushing your little one’s teeth, and she steadfastly closes her mouth and
refuses to open. Forcing the issue runs the risk of creating more reason for
her to resist in the future, while allowing her to win risks sending the
message that you can be defeated if she only waits long enough. An alternative
approach is to allow her a minute to refuse, while you wait, toothbrush in
hand, perhaps saying something like: “ok, I see you are not ready to brush your
teeth yet.” This sends the message that she has the right to participate in the
process, she can get to choose to say no; but that you are not willing to give
up on the eventual outcome. Again, if we emphasize the underlying meaning of
this example, rather than viewing it as a simple technique, the message is that
your expectations are to be respected, but that she gets to have a say too.
This takes more time, but then again, may end up taking less time than the
fight which can be the alternative.
The hardest part of this approach is that it requires you as
the parent/caregiver to come in touch with the feelings that are generated in
you. For example, the toothbrush example comes from personal experience. I wanted
my child to get finished with brushing his teeth and get to bed in order for me
to move on with all the other things I needed to do that evening. I felt
frustration, even some anger that he wouldn’t comply: “doesn’t he know that I
have other things to do?!” Of course, the answer is he does not, nor does he
care. Nor can he possibly have much understanding of what my life is like aside
from my caretaking responsibilities which have immediately to do with him. But
children are exquisitely sensitive to emotions. If anger had crept into my
voice as I tried to acknowledge his need to take over the process, he would
have sensed it. That doesn’t mean I was not aware of, or denied that feeling
within myself, only that I worked to keep it out of the room and out of my
interaction with him.
And that is really the key: They have a need for control in
their lives, much as we do, even if the specific goals and desires are
obviously different. Where their need to say “no” encounters our own
intentions, that is where problems happen. There is no one way, or some simple
answer for how to have an effective and collaborative relationship with your
child. Rather, parenting requires a careful balance between allowing them to
feel that they have some control over their bodies, their lives, and over us in
some ways and to some degree. But also learning how to listen to our feelings
so that parenting becomes healthy compromise rather than into a battle that we
need to win, or that we allow the child to win.
About
me: I am a Licensed Psychologist in private practice. Among my
interests is working with couples on relationship and parenting issues.
My office is in Conshohocken, and I can be reached at (484) 534-8830 or
at dan.livney@gmail.com. For more information, please see his website
at www.danlivney.com